David Lloyd - Sky Sports Expert

Wales of discontent

Why are we not using our strongholds against Australia?

Posted: 05th September 2008 10:24

Subscribe to RSS FeedSubscribe to RSS Feed Send an email to David LloydEmail David Lloyd

Kevin Pietersen Peter Moores SWALEC Stadium

Moores & Pietersen: in Cardiff

Before we begin, let me declare that I'm part-Welsh.

My grandparents are from Cardiff and I'm quite passionate about Wales, but I'm sorry, I can't see how the SWALEC Stadium is a Test match venue.

It doesn't fit with me that it's going to be used for the first Test of the Ashes and it has clearly not been chosen for cricketing reasons.

It's nice, but it just doesn't look finished. It looks more like an out ground in New Zealand than a proper Test match stadium.

If you want to know what a Test match venue looks like, then look at Durham. It has good views, wonderful scenery and it looks and feels like a proper stadium, even though it's a new build.

I was mixing with a lot of the media on Wednesday afternoon and nobody had a good word to say about the place. One unnamed journalist said the SWALEC Stadium looked more like Toy Town.

You'd expect a new build to take notice of the media - both written and electronic - when it was designed. They clearly haven't.

The camera positions have not got stations in critical areas and the viewing areas for electronic media are obscured. The windows are not full windows and have got the thickest frames I've ever seen.

There's been a financial inducement from the Welsh Assembly, which is obviously tax-payers' money, and that must have something to do with why it has been chosen ahead of Old Trafford for the Ashes.

Stronghold

Another thing I need to declare is that I have no affinity with Lancashire County Cricket Club.

But how Old Trafford can miss out on a Test match is beyond me. The North West is heaving with people, heaving with sport and has a venue that is very accessible, holds 22,000 people and England love playing there. Monty Panesar says he'd like to wrap that pitch up and take it round with him!

The two England stronghold venues are Trent Bridge (swing) and Old Trafford (pace, spin) and neither of them are being used for the Ashes.

Somebody has made that decision. I'm not sure who it was, but I'll tell you who it wasn't - Peter Moores.

There's no way that he's been consulted about where he wants to play Australia to have the best chance of winning.

Home advantage

People ask should you have home advantage?

There's going to be a Ryder Cup very soon and the lay-out at Valhalla will suit the home team.

The aprons will be left to grow so Europe can't bump and run and you've got to play target golf and hit the pin.

The home team will know all of the positions a week in advance, while the European team will find out on the morning of each day. So the Americans are clearly taking home advantage.

England don't play anybody more important than Australia and I think people need to know that England's stronghold venues are not being used.

I'll stress again I have nothing against the Welsh - and I'll thump anybody that has! - but it is not the place to play Australia.

I'm quite embarrassed that's where the first Test is going to he held.

Man management

Without doubt, England have got a very good one-day team now.

Kevin's next port of call is to tell a number of players that they're not playing for £500,000. That's going to take very good man-management.

Only 11 men can play in the Stanford match and have that chance of winning £500,000 each. Some people need to be told: 'sorry mate, you're not playing'.

There's no room for sentiment. When Sir Alex Ferguson or Arsene Wenger are playing for the big prizes they pick their best team.

I'll put a spanner in the works straight away. The best Twenty20 player I've seen this year is Graham Napier, so pick him and move on from there.

He loses a cricket ball, he bowls at 87mph full at the stumps and he fields like a dream. If he doesn't get in that team then England must have some great Twenty20 players.

There are tough decisions for Kevin and the management to make, but they've got to pick the best team possible.

Bumble answers your questions...

Send your questions to Bumble by filling in the feedback form below. Or you can mail them in by clicking HERE

Dear Mr Lloyd (or may I call you Bumble) Please can you put in a word with the right places and do something about the music at the cricket matches this year - if I hear Howzat, Always Look on the Bright Side, Na Na Na Hey Hey (and a few of the others) much more I am going to scream or something worse. All the grounds play the same music at the same times in the match. Is there an agreement to only play certain tunes, or have they just no imagination?! Surely the commentators must get fed up with the same music too. Janette Saunders.

BUMBLE SAYS: Janette, we're singing from the same hymn sheet. I agree the music is absolutely dire and monotonous, particularly at Twenty20 matches. I've suggested that if it's at Manchester they should play Manchester bands, Midlands bands in Birmingham etc. They should work on that theme to provide some variety. I don't understand why it doesn't change.

If you're interested Janette, I'm doing a programme for Radio Kent in a few weeks' time where I'll get to play my top 10 tunes. It's on a Sunday afternoon and I'm not sure if Kent will be ready for me because I'm going to pick some absolute rockers. I've warned them I'm not a 61-year-old man who likes Frank Sinatra and Tony Bennett, it's going to be rocking alternative: The New York Dolls, The Fall, ACDC, Metallica and more. I'll give them 10 tracks and I'll dare them to play them. I can't wait to hear the half Man Half Biscuit song 'Lord Hereford's Knob' - which, as everybody knows, is about a hill in South Wales.

Hi Bumble. I am a steward at Somerset ground Taunton. The weather here has been good all day - Wednesday - just one shower. Should be playing at Taunton just 40 miles south of Cardiff. The England women's team have been training this morning for tomorrow's game. How about a bit of publicity for them? On Monday we had less than 200 people in the ground to watch the one-day international. Regards, John Wooler

BUMBLE SAYS: They're a good set of lads, those girls! They're sparky lasses and they're definitely going the right way in cricketing terms. They're infinitely better than they used to be and they're just about the best women's team in the world now. The best players have central contracts with the ECB, which is a really good idea.

As for giving them a bit of publicity, they've been live on Sky this week and I haven't seen them on any other TV channel. People are sometimes too quick to complain about cricket being on Sky. One of the joys of working for this company is that it covers every aspect of cricket from all levels. We do Club Life during every Test match where we go to three amateur clubs, we have a commitment to women's cricket and we give great exposure to youth cricket. This company is the business and that's why I enjoy working for them.

Send your questions to Bumble by filling in the feedback form below. Or you can mail them in by clicking HERE

Comments

Nathan Brown says...

Fantastic article Bumble, I agree with everything in it. India will be using home advantage when we tour there by taking us to all of India's out grounds where the crowds can be very hostile and intimadating but England always let other countries go to Lord's instead of using our "stronghold venues". We need to make decisions for the best interests of English cricket.

Posted 22:17 14th September 2008

Nick Hayward says...

Bumble, I am a big fan of your commentary but your comments about the Swalec stadium are crazy. Did you not notice that the stadium is part of glorius Cardiff parkland. It is about time that Wales got some recognition in the cricketing world. After all, the ECB represents Wales as well. For too long now our players have been overlooked for some average ones at other counties. If you want to start moaning about something, try getting the ECB changed to the EWCB. I have been on a tour of the Swalec and I can assure you that the facilities are first class. A new drainage system and more covers this winter will solve many problems. If you visit Sophia Gardens on a nice day you will see that there is no better place to watch cricket. And as for views , what on earth surrounds Old Trafford, Lords, The Oval, Headingley and Edgbaston that you can describe as a view !!! The Swalec is in parkland for heavens's sake. Headlingley is one of the ugliest grounds on the circuit. It is about time cricket broadened it's horizons and moved around other counties for tests. I am all for The Rose Bowl and Riverside. Maybe they could get an Ashes test next time. James Harris for England !!

Posted 13:38 12th September 2008

Richard Jones says...

For Bumble to say that he has no affinity with Lancashire is simply not true. He is rightly very proud of his long connection with a famous club but he (and others like Atherton and Allott) cannot get over Cardiff being awared the Ashes test in favour of Old Trafford. You cant judge a ground on a day like last Wednesday. I have been to Old Trafford in the rain and it is not a nice place to be. Cardiff has loads to recommend it and the infrastructure is in place. We have hosted a Rugy World Cup Final, FA Cup Finals etc. The ground is 10 minutes' walk from a main line railway station and the city centre. All the grounds offer different things and Cardiff offers plenty. On a sunny day with a full house that ground will rock. Dont judge it on a rained off game and get over a decision that was made 3 years ago.

Posted 10:21 10th September 2008

Paul Mokler says...

Stop moaning, Bumble! Not like you, as you're normally the life and soul of the party. Are you Bob (Every silver lining has a cloud) Willis in disguise?! The stadium could be even better, if we could build a bigger stand at the River Taff End. Cardiff is a fantastic city, with great bars, restaurants and nightlife. You might pull ! Crofty will take you out on the town. Try the Brains Smooth. Get over it and enjoy it ! Glamorgan have sunk a fortune into this stadium project, at the expense of the team. Good luck to the likes of Glamorgan, Durham and Hampshire in trying to build quality stadia. The Welsh are just as passionate as the English, and I'll find EWE a nice sheep.

Posted 17:15 9th September 2008

Mark Dowling says...

Bumble, nothing against the Welsh, but an Ashes series is not the occasion to try out a new test venue. I'm sure the "teething troubles" you refer to will be ironed out by next Summer, but I'm a big fan of the traditional venues for such an important series. Pity Napier didn't make the Stanford squad - what happened to, "horses for courses" ?

Posted 15:42 9th September 2008

Lee Jones says...

Thank you Bumble. You get a lot of people slagging off the Riverside Ground at Chester-le-Street, but, as you so rightly say, it is a great ground. Although it's modern, it still looks like a proper cricket grounds, with the stands around the ground all pretty distinct from each other. Also, the wicket always provides a good contest between bat and ball. I can't wait for the proposed work on the ground to be done. The Riverside will be one of the most attractive grounds in the world. Also, agree with you about the SWALEC Stadium. It doesn't really look like a cricket ground. I undetstand making it a test venue, but not for the 1st Ashes test, that should really be at Lord's. And I sympathise with Lancashire CCC too, Old Trafford really does deserve at least 1 test match next year.

Posted 16:04 8th September 2008

Mark Coldwell says...

David, very unimpressed by your `swalec stadium` comments I think your still reeling because cardiff was chosen ahead of that tired old stadium up north, get over it and embrace us welsh. As for the lack of scenery, did you not notice the parks, castle river,millenium stadium etc etc. Agree with your Napier comments though, a good fast skiddy bowler who peppers the stands at ease, hit 3 sixes in a row at the swalec a couple of months ago `bod cerddedig 'ch bagan`

Posted 13:51 8th September 2008

Stuart Barry says...

Bumble, When are you going to have a coup and sieze power at the EWCB ? You are so right about the next Ashes series. Only England seem capable of so perfectly knobbling themselves , can you imagine the Aussies opting not to play at the WACA or the 'Gabba? As a Lancastrian living in Australia I can assure those who "run" the game in England and Wales that people over here are amazed...and amused ,that two of the grounds most advantageous to England are not to be used for the Ashes. If you cannot sieze power in time to improve our chances in the Ashes , can you use your considerable influence to get "Shooting Yourself in the Foot" included as an event for the 2012 Olympics - we'd be a certainty for gold on this form.

Posted 14:58 6th September 2008

Andrew Mccarthy says...

Really disappointed by all of your anti Cardiff comments. There is still a lot of work to do at the Swalec stadium which will be perfect for the first ashes match. We are part of the England and Wales Cricket Board and as such I believe we have a right to bid for test matches the same as other clubs do in England. As for saying it looks like toy town - take a look at some of the venues that have been used over the years which are simply awful. We have been given a chance and everyone has to start somewhere - are you seriously telling me that everyone got it 150% right first time, I doubt it. As for the weather - perhaps it would be easier just to announce the venue on the morning of the game then we can all travel to where the sun is?? I don't know what we in Cardiff were supposed to do with the rain - perhaps you blinkered lot in sky have a hot line to god and manage to book the weather for each of your English based fixtures. Do everyone a favour - cricket needs to grow and embrace youngsters of which Wales has hundreds - give Cardiff and for that matter Wales a chance. They need your support and supportive criticism not your constant snipping for clubs you obviously loyalty to.

Posted 14:16 6th September 2008

Michael Trainor says...

Well done Bumble for grasping the nettle and not being a slave to political correctness. CRICKET FOR CRICKET VENUES ONLY PLEASE. Old Trafford is steeped in cricket and to leave it out verges on sporting blasphemy. This is the Ashes for goodness sake not some lazy sunday afternoon on the village green. Maybe these other areas and venues could demonstrate thier cricketing bona fides before being handed such a prestigious award.

Posted 10:48 6th September 2008

Pete Ghattas says...

I've never heard such a load of old rubbish. As an Englishman (from Manchester),living in Wales, I think the Welsh should be proud of the SWALEC stadium. Whilst I'm sure there were some teething problems on Wednesday, what is undeniable are the horrendous conditions for the whole of this week, culminating in flooding across the country. Any test match ground would have failed to get a game on Wednesday had they endured the same weather conditions. As for the ground itself, it's in a fantastic location, 10 mins walk from the city centre through beautiful parklands, maybe you didn't notice it Bumble as you arrived in your chauffeur driven car. The doubters will knock Cardiff regardless, as you have proved Bumble, but spare us from all this territorial nonsense.

Posted 23:52 5th September 2008

Sam Barnett says...

Bumble, good article, why are we depriving grounds like Trent Bridge, Old Trafford etc. of the Ashes? Well I guess I know the answer: money, but it isn't a satisfactory answer. PS. Hate to be cynical, but both of your answers to questions promote something: Radio Kent and Sky.... nah, I'm too suspicious.

Posted 21:31 5th September 2008

Peter Banner says...

Dear Bumble (why) with, in my opinion, the greatist fast bowler in the world commentating, (no sorry bumble not you), being the superb Michael Holding, has he, or would he do any coaching to Englands bowlers or up and coming young bowlers if he was asked and if he has not been asked why has he not been asked. Regards Peter

Posted 20:13 5th September 2008

Craig Bristol says...

I'd like to echo the points raised by Bumble, but, I'd like to raise another; What about the West Country? We always miss out. The South West is the biggest region in the whole of England with droves of passionate cricketing fans and we have no Test match venue. Sure we get the odd ODI at the County Ground and it ALWAYS sells out if England come to Bristol but why should London get more than one Test regularly and other regions get chosen ahead of us? Kid us all you like ECB but it's not for the benefit of the fans. Now even Wales has got a Test match in the Swalego Ground for political reasons. It's pathetic.

Posted 14:27 5th September 2008

Marcus "eddie the eagle" Bennett says...

Dear Bumble, Being ever so biased, i'm all for Mr Napier to be given a chance for the Stanford match, but suspect that while his name might get mentioned by the selectors, thats about as far as it goes, and i'm pretty certain, that whilst its an entirely different form of the game, because the One Day side are doing so well, they will pretty much select that squad with maybe one or two faces coming in, but probably also coming from in or around the general England set-up. Napier bowls at 90mph (to some cricketing pundits shock! I'd love to know which journalist it was that said Napiers bowling would hold him back from England as he only bowled military medum!) and proved at the FP Final he's up for the big occassion. His batting speaks for itself, and I really don't think the the Stanford XI would be all that happy seeing someone of his ability coming in to bat at number 8 or 9! (Or possibly higher up the order....). Anyway, I'm off now to go and support my beloved Essex as they play Hampshire in the Floodlit Cup game at Chelmsford, an end of season Twenty20 affair. I shall be wandering around the ground with the new bat that Warsop Stebbing made me as Eddie the Eagle, and let me tell you, like Napiers bat, its a work of art! Special Eagle stickers on the front, and my name emblazoned down the spine... and I reckon it could hit a few 6's too! Do you think Eddie might have a chance of a call up for the Stanford game?!?!? I'm pretty sure the £500,000 would buy me a lovely new nest!

Posted 14:05 5th September 2008

Harb Pabla says...

Bumble, why were so many one dayers this summer being played during the weekdays? Is it because the cricket has become so commercialised that the itenary has to fit in with the men in suits?

Posted 12:56 5th September 2008

Page 1 of 1

Add Comment*

All fields are required

Are you a Sky Sports subscriber?

Character Count : 0/1950

Please tick here if you wish to receive emails relating to Sky Sports.com or any other companies, services or products related to Sky Sports.com

Please send me the weekly Sky Sportszine - exclusive content, features and competitions to my inbox every Friday.

*All fields required, your email address will be kept private